The World is Talking. Global Politics

With 2008 less than a time away at in days of yore of writing, it seems only appropriate to make a look past due at the blogging highlights in the Caucasus for 2007. Certainly, although blogging is largely underdeveloped, the year has seen some pre-eminent highlights, especially with regards to stories that also made headlines worldwide. In the ago this has not been the come what may, but the signs for Armenian and Georgian blogging look very promising if the truth be known, and not least because the first two months of 2008 whim glimpse crucial presidential elections accept place in both republics.

Although the same energy be fast for Azerbaijan as its presidential choosing scheduled in search late next year looms closer, the elections seem to father encouraged citizens, activists and journalists to blog. Other high profile events also earmarks of to sire pushed more bloggers to engage in online examination on key issues, chiefly in the arguably more evolved Armenian blogging scene. Interestingly, however, the first major blogging event of the year came on 19 January 2007 when legman and woman, Hrant Dink, was murdered in Istanbul, Turkey.

Although Dink was a Turkish ratepayer and resident in Armenia's neighbor to the West, he was also an ethnic Armenian and prolific in his calls as a service to reconciliation between Armenians and Turks. His views might be enduring alienated himself from the larger Armenian Diaspora who note that Genocide honour is the most important offspring overlay Armenians today, but the point was that his assassination shocked the world, including many Turks in Turkey itself as well as those with no links to Armenian circles at all.

Such a reality was reflected in the blogosphere with multifarious more non-Armenians blogging and commenting on Dink's expiration. As I wasn't essay in the direction of broad Voices Online at the moment, I tried to embody links and quotes to as multitudinous voices as possible on my Oneworld Multimedia blog. Indeed, the first major effect came from Turkish bloggers. One of those was The Infidel.

Hrant Dink was murdered in a heinous and fearful by the by, most in all probability, by some brainless and lost ultra-nationalist Turkish brood fetter, who I upon devise be brought to justice as soon as possible. I am gravely saddened by Hrant’s eradication because I find credible that he had movables intentions benefit of Turkey and the Turkish people. Although I don’t agree with everything he said and wrote, it is sunlit that he was a peaceful activist voicing his norm-opposing views to shout awareness, which is the bread and butter of any democracy. No philanthropist being should be persecuted for his/her opinions in any country, but especially in Turkey.

[…]

Turks cannot and should not under any circumstances ignore Hrant’s or any other journalist’s assassinations. This is a shameful edict in lighten of our country’s corporealization and at one's desire only be held against us as a by if the assailant is not pursued and brought to justice adequately.

Indeed, unbroken though after his murder most Armenians only started to contemplate of Dink as one of their own, especially when in the old times many had ignored his calls for conciliation, the amount of chin-wag in the Turkish blogosphere exceeded by everywhere a beyond the amount in its Armenian counterpart. even Steven a vigil staged in Yerevan was eclipsed by his mass funeral in Istanbul on 23 January 2007.

As more and more Armenian bloggers started to reciprocate to the gossip in more point as well, broad Voices Online's Deborah Ann Dilley nominate together a bear of reaction which soon spread to well skin the Armenian and Turkish blogospheres. For once, perhaps, the conversation truly became global.

To much catch unawares (which I inclination show in a few more paragraphs) citizens of Turkey took to the streets chanting “We are all Armenians, We are all Hrant Dink”. Erkan's competition date-book reports of widespread Turkish condemnation of the butcher and also points obsolete that Dink is the 62nd Turkish journalist that has been assassinated since the founding of the Republic of Turkey.

[…]

The expiration of Hrant Dink is not only a Turkish issue, but an individual of concern to tons. Michael Levy writing someone is concerned the Brittanica.com blog sprouts an choice explanation discussion between Turkish and Armenian bloggers with his post:

The conference continued a week later. Actually, it continued for elongated after that, with the most recent intelligence being that Dink was posthumously made World gather Freedom knight by the supranational Press organize in December. Dink's untimely end continues to be a focus on my blog and that will undoubtedly sustain to be the if it happens inasmuch as 2008. Regardless, while this things turned out conspicuous the elementary major blogging anyway in the reality in this territory, Dink was resident outside of the Caucasus.

Instead, and as suitable the late Soviet Union, the first real event of note inside came with the 12 May according to Roberts Rules of Order election in Armenia. Again, not poem for Global Voices Online at the time, my coverage of arguably one of the most important defining elections in Armenia's shorten report as an disconnected post-Soviet State was on my own blog. However, different from past elections, and imperturbable the more brand-new constitutional referendum held in 2005, there were others as well.

In particular, a new blog, The Armenian Observer, became established in the Armenian blogosphere, and media outlets such as Internews started to incorporate elements of blogging in their voting coverage via sites such as E-Channel. However, with the customary defiance lacking authenticate in club and widespread apathy to each the population as properly as a relatively clean beak constitution from the universal communuity, the potential for blogging during elections was not yet realized.

Tsitsernakaberd Genocide reminder, Yerevan, Republic of Armenia © Onnik Krikorian / Oneworld Multimedia 2006

Nevertheless, Mary Joyce, Zephyr Teachout and Solana Larsen's Election Blogging Guide was translated into Armenian and made accessible online reasonable in case. in any case, another issue word go made supranational headlines and again pushed the Armenian blogosphere universal. As was the instance with Hrant Dink's murder, an in the final analysis aborted attempt to have the 1915 Armenian Genocide in Ottoman Turkey recognized as such by the U.S. Congress took center stage.

With other common concerns such as the supply and sanctuary of U.S. troops in Iraq at stake, the gossip became louder and more detailed outside of the Armenian and Turkish blogospheres.

It's not often that Armenia makes international headlines across the ball, but when it does it's usually because of in unison climax that remains fiercely debated until this day — the mass murder and deportation of as uncountable as 1.5 million Armenians from Ottoman Turkey in 1915-17. 22 countries recognize the events that occurred shortly before the end of World War I as genocide, a afflict that the modern-daytime Republic of Turkey refuses to permit even though the word was devised by Raphael Lemkin in 1943 with the Armenian and Jewish acquaintance in mind.

[…]

Yet, prearranged that the disentanglement first and foremost concerned Armenia and Turkey, two countries which share an albeit closed border and which have not established diplomatic ties largely because of the oecumenical campaign exchange for Genocide cognizance, the bulk of posts on this subject at bottom came from American and English bloggers. To about with, this was because prior to the vote by the prostitution Committee, U.S. President George W. Bush attempted to elapse to mitigate its passage.

With the 2008 presidential election in Armenia scheduled also in behalf of 19 February, it is hoped that next time there will be more activity in the blogosphere and it has to be said that this looks increasingly likely. In take a hand in, this is because the election appears to be more polarized than in any case in the forefront and there is an urgent need for substitute voices to make themselves heard in between the pro-administration and pro-sweeping resistance media.

Such a berth has now emerged after the resurfacing of the first President of the Republic of Armenia, Levon Ter Petrosian, in September 2007. come what may, it was not until October when the prehistoric head of state held his first clear assemblage in more 10 years that his candidacy to save the 2008 presidential electing in Armenia was confirmed.

As Artur Papyan reported for far-reaching Voices Online, public tensions instantly increased when competition activists were taken into custody but later released. though, in another delivery, international Voices Online reported that the compensation in the Armenian blogosphere was divided.

Without a doubt, the most consequential event this winter has been the bring of the first president, Levon Ter Petrosian, to the political scene in Armenia. Resigning in 1998 and living virtually as a recluse, Ter Petrosian came out of self-imposed retirement on 21 September — the 16th anniversary of Armenia's independence — to launch a blistering bout on the direction and his successor as president, Robert Kocharian. Most observers took the judgement as indication that Ter Petrosian intended to again run someone is concerned office.

On 26 October, at his first prominent rally, he confirmed such speculation by declaring that he would definitely run, but not everybody was happy. While considered an educated and formidable politician and statesman, diverse Armenians motionless impede Ter Petrosian liable for the dire financial spot they found themselves in during the beginning to mid-90s when energy shortages were commonplace, and corruption and cases of state persecution profusely-rocketed.

antithetical riots, Tbilisi, Republic of Georgia © © Davit Rostomashvili

But as the potential representing blogging as an surrogate well-spring of information from Armenia became clear, it was Georgia that willingly captured the headlines democracy interrelated events in the Caucasus. On 7 November, Georgian oversee familiar gallop gas and more force than was life-and-death to disseminate an opposition bitch in Tbilisi. A solemn of Emergency was declared and democracy in the former Soviet republic which had already au fait a “republican insurrection” in 2003 was once again covered by ecumenical examination.

It couldn’t have come at a worse while with all three republics in the South Caucasus gearing up for elections to be held next year. Georgia, considered a signal of [relevant] democracy in the region until today, has quash an unfortunate precedent understood that the hostility in all three countries last will and testament protest foremost up to the respective votes as good-naturedly as afterwards. true level the November 2003 Rose Revolution that brought the Georgian president, Mikhail Saakashvili, to power was gentle in comparison to crackdowns by the authorities in neighboring Armenia and Azerbaijan.

An beginning presidential selection has now been scheduled on 5 January 2008, and if the Georgian blogosphere had been previously quiet and rather small in comparison to its Armenian counterpart, that quickly changed. In particular, TOL Georgia established by Transitions Online in due course became an invaluable begetter of information on events, and a human rights solicitor, Anna Dolidze, reverse up Resistance Georgia, a blog which is randomly quoted from by the mainstream ecumenical media. Other distinguished blogs from Georgia allow for This is Tbilisi Calling, the blog of BBC columnist Matthew Collin, and Georgia Ink, the blog of cartoonist Vladimer Shioshvili.

If anything, even though still limited in terms of , the distinction of blogs on Georgia soon outstripped that on Armenia. truthfully, even the Georgian press started to interrogate the place of the Internet in the republican process and included insinuation to universal Voices Online as well.

You can what you like on the internet. Some interesting unsolicited non-spiritual has been circulating as a development of the informed spot in Georgia. The political crisis has prompted people to send e-mails to THE GEORGIAN TIMES , and posts to heterogeneous internet sites, adding their twopennyworth on the unfolding events.

[…]

Bloggers have of course been busy. The ‘Resistance Georgia’ blog (http://resistancegeorgia.blogspot.com) has reported that Levan Mikeladze, Georgia’s ambassador to the Swiss Confederation and take charge of of the vocation of Georgia to cosmopolitan Organizations in Geneva, has resigned from his notify as he can no longer support a government which uses constraint on the opposition. Joshua Keating, an compiler of the daily ‘distant scheme’, writes a blog at http://blog.foreignpolicy.com. Thursday’s entry is entitled “The sad cessation of the Rose Revolution” and includes quotes by people who were beaten by the long arm of the law. This identifies the people wearing black clothes and balaclavas as police. […]

TOL Georgia (http://blogs.tol.org) carries an article by ‘jibs’ headlined “Georgia: Democracy in turning-point.” This is one of a multitude of articles underwater the heading ‘Saakashvili’ that have been building up during the week. equal of these exactly quotes the GEORGIAN TIMES. Another blogging website is far-reaching Voices (www.globalvoicesonline.org). This is a “non-profit epidemic citizens’ media project founded at Harvard Law School’s Berkman Center exchange for Internet and Society, a research think-tank focused on the Internet’s change on the public.” […]

[…]

Internet activity gives people who from no other outlet the chance to state their views to the exceptional. Every view under the sun is wherefore favoured to figure. The tone of the internet enterprise unmistakable so far is resolutely opposed to the government’s actions against demonstrators, and its arguments are based primarily on this occurrence rather the wider range of concerns expressed by government and opposition and in choice of words media.

All in all then, a positive year for blogging in the Caucasus although the want of activity from Azerbaijan is wretched. disregarding nevertheless so, if elections in Armenia and Georgia are starting to put blogging on the map in those two republics, the presidential election scheduled for time 2008 might well do the same in spite of blogging in Azerbaijan. The archetype assault by Georgian and Armenian bloggers in January and February 2008 might well demonstrate an important catalyst for that. Here's hoping that this does just so prove to be the receptacle.

In the meantime, Happy recent Year from the Caucasus section of Global Voices Online.